If you’re craving something sweet after your warm, toasty sandwich at Potbelly, you’re in luck. The Potbelly Desserts Menu is a hidden gem, full of freshly baked cookies, rich chocolate brownies, and seasonal sweets that turn a simple meal into a satisfying treat.
In this ultimate guide, we’ll break down the full Potbelly desserts menu with prices, highlight popular picks, reveal secret tips to customize your dessert, and answer the most frequently asked questions. This is your complete 2025 dessert breakdown, optimized for dessert lovers, foodies, and Potbelly Rewards members.
View Full: Potbelly Menu With Prices
Order now: PbDelivery®
Potbelly Dessert Menu with Prices
| Dessert Item | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Brownie | Fudgy, chocolate-packed square brownie | $2.49 |
| Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie | Chewy cookie with oats and rich chocolate chips | $1.89 |
| Sugar Cookie | Soft classic Sugar Cookie, buttery and sweet | $1.89 |
| Dream Bar | A layered bar with chocolate, coconut, and graham cracker | $2.49 |
| Mini Cookie Snack Pack | Bite-sized cookies great for kids or on-the-go | $1.99 |
| Banana Pudding | Creamy Banana Pudding with vanilla wafers | $3.29 |
| Seasonal Cookies | Limited-time offers like Pumpkin Spice or Peppermint | $2.09 |
Fan Favorite Desserts at Potbelly
Want to know what customers love most? These top-rated sweets always get rave reviews:
- Chocolate Brownie – Rich, dense, and best served slightly warm.
- Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie – A nostalgic favorite with a hearty texture.
- Dream Bar – Think of it as a dessert mash-up: coconut + chocolate + crunch.
If you’re visiting Potbelly for the first time, we highly recommend trying the brownie or the dream bar.
Nutritional Information for Potbelly Desserts
| Dessert Item | Calories |
|---|---|
| Chocolate Brownie | 370 Cal |
| Oatmeal Choco Chip Cookie | 350 Cal |
| Sugar Cookie | 330 Cal |
| Dream Bar | 390 Cal |
| Banana Pudding | 420 Cal |
| Seasonal Cookie (Pumpkin) | 360 Cal |
Are Potbelly Desserts Gluten-Free or Vegan?
Most Potbelly desserts contain gluten, dairy, and eggs, making them unsuitable for vegan or gluten-free diets. However, some locations test gluten-free chocolate chip cookies or vegan brownies, especially in metro areas or during holiday promotions.
Vegetarian Options:
- ✅ All cookies and brownies are vegetarian (not vegan).
Vegan Options:
- ❌ No guaranteed vegan desserts currently available nationwide.
Gluten-Free:
- ❌ Most desserts contain wheat.
- ✔️ Occasionally: Gluten-free cookie during special promos.
Customization Options for Desserts
Make your dessert experience even better by customizing:
- Heat it up: Ask the staff to warm your brownie or cookie for extra gooeyness.
- Pair it with a shake: Combine with a Potbelly milkshake for a DIY dessert combo.
- Toppings: Some locations offer whipped cream, chocolate drizzle, or caramel on Dream Bars and puddings.
Dessert Deals with Potbelly Perks Rewards
If you’re a Potbelly Perks member, you get:
- Free dessert on your birthday
- Exclusive dessert offers (like BOGO cookies)
- Bonus points on sweet purchases
Download the Potbelly app to stay updated on promos and offers.
Best Potbelly Desserts to Pair With Your Meal
| Meal Item | Recommended Dessert Pairing |
|---|---|
| Italian Sandwich | Chocolate Brownie |
| A Wreck Sandwich | Oatmeal Choco Chip Cookie |
| Chicken Pot Pie Soup | Sugar Cookie |
| Grilled Chicken Salad | Dream Bar |
| Roast Beef Sandwich | Banana Pudding |
| Turkey Club | Seasonal Cookie (like Peppermint) |
Potbelly Seasonal Desserts
Potbelly typically releases seasonal desserts around major U.S. holidays:
- Valentine’s Day: Chocolate-Dipped Heart Cookies
- Spring/Easter: Lemon Sugar Cookie
- Fall: Pumpkin Spice Cookie & Pecan Bars
- Winter: Peppermint Bark Cookie
Keep an eye on the Potbelly app or email newsletter for drop announcements.
How to Order Potbelly Desserts Online
You can order all desserts through:
- Potbelly Website: Choose your location > Start your order > Go to “Sweets”
- Potbelly App: Access rewards, deals, and mobile ordering
- Delivery Services: Available on DoorDash, Uber Eats, Grubhub (may vary by area)
FAQ: Potbelly Desserts Menu
1. What is the most popular dessert at Potbelly?
The Chocolate Brownie and Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie are top sellers.
2. Does Potbelly have gluten-free desserts?
Not usually, but limited-time gluten-free cookies may appear seasonally.
3. Are Potbelly cookies made in-house?
Yes, all cookies and brownies are baked fresh daily at each location.
4. Is Potbelly’s banana pudding available year-round?
It’s often seasonal. Availability depends on the location and time of year.
5. Can I order a warm brownie at Potbelly?
Absolutely. Just ask the staff to heat it up.
6. Does Potbelly sell desserts in bulk?
You can order cookie packs or catering dessert trays for events.
7. Are any Potbelly desserts nut-free?
The sugar cookie and brownie are generally nut-free, but always ask due to cross-contact risk.
8. Can you earn Potbelly Perks points for desserts?
Yes. All dessert purchases qualify for Perks points.
9. Are desserts included in Potbelly meal combos?
Sometimes. During promotions, you can add a dessert for less.
10. Does Potbelly offer sugar-free dessert options?
Currently, there are no sugar-free items on the dessert menu.
11. Can I customize my cookie (e.g., toppings)?
Some locations allow whipped cream or sauces on select items.
12. Is there a kid-friendly dessert menu?
Yes! The Mini Cookie Snack Pack is a great child-sized option.
13. What’s the highest-calorie dessert at Potbelly?
The Dream Bar and Banana Pudding are among the most calorie-dense options.
14. Do Potbelly cookies contain eggs?
Yes. All baked desserts include eggs unless otherwise stated.
15. How can I find the latest dessert promotions?
Check the Potbelly app or sign up for their emails to receive seasonal deals.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re in the mood for a fudgy brownie or something a little lighter like banana pudding, the Potbelly Desserts Menu delivers big on flavor and freshness. Perfect for finishing off a meal or grabbing a sweet on-the-go, these desserts are crafted with the same care as their famous sandwiches.
If you haven’t tried one yet—you’re missing out. Grab a cookie (or three), and thank us later.