In the world of fast-casual dining, Potbelly Sandwich reigns supreme with its unique blend of toasted subs, creamy shakes, crispy sides, and a welcoming neighborhood vibe. But there’s more to this sandwich chain than meets the eye.
From its iconic “A Wreck” to underrated vegetarian gems like the Veggie Melt, the Potbelly Sandwich Menu in 2025 offers hearty, satisfying options for every craving—whether you’re a meat lover or looking for lighter bites.
We’ll cover every Potbelly sandwich with nutrition facts, menu prices, ordering hacks, secret menu items, and even region-specific tips to help you order smarter and eat better.
View Full: Potbelly Menu With Prices
Order now: PbDelivery®
Potbelly Sandwiches Menu
A Wreck
| Price | Cal |
| $11.29 | 655 |
Italian
| Price | Cal |
| $11.29 | 775 |
Avo Turkey
| Price | Cal |
| $12.29 | 640 |
Pizza Melt
| Price | Cal |
| $11.29 | 628 |
Mediterranean
| Price | Cal |
| $12.29 | 621 |
Mama’s Meatball
| Price | Cal |
| $11.29 | 730 |
Turkey Breast
| Price | Cal |
| $10.89 | 638 |
Smoked Ham
| Price | Cal |
| $10.89 | 715 |
Roast Beef
| Price | Cal |
| $10.89 | 617 |
PB&J
| Price | Cal |
| $9.99 | 608 |
Full Potbelly Sandwiches Menu List
Meat Lovers’ Favorites
| Sandwich | Price | Calories | Ingredients |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Wreck | $11.29 | 714 | Turkey, ham, roast beef, salami, Swiss |
| Italian | $11.29 | 774 | Salami, capicola, pepperoni, mortadella, provolone |
| Avo Turkey | $12.29 | 642 | Turkey, Swiss, avocado, cucumbers |
Chicken Specialties
| Sandwich | Price | Calories | Ingredients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chicken Club | $12.29 | 690 | Grilled chicken, bacon, cheddar |
| Grilled Chicken | $10.89 | 573 | Grilled chicken, cheddar |
| Chicken Salad | $10.89 | 761 | Chicken salad, provolone |
Vegetarian Picks
| Sandwich | Price | Calories | Ingredients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mediterranean | $12.29 | 621 | Chicken (optional), feta, hummus, artichoke, peppers, cucumbers |
| Veggie Melt | $11.29 | 465 | Avocado, Swiss, cheddar, provolone, mushrooms |
All Other Sandwiches
| Sandwich | Price | Calories | Ingredients |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prime Rib Steak | $13.29 | 715 | Prime rib, Swiss, onions, garlic aioli |
| Cubano | $11.29 | 663 | Pulled pork, ham, Swiss, mustard, pickles |
| Sweet Heat Pork BBQ | $11.49 | 753 | Pulled pork, cheddar, pickles, spicy BBQ sauce |
| BLTA | $11.79 | 612 | Bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado |
| Pizza Melt | $11.29 | 625 | Pepperoni, capicola, meatball, marinara, provolone |
| Mama’s Meatball | $11.29 | 727 | Meatballs, marinara, provolone, Italian seasoning |
| Turkey Breast | $10.89 | 638 | Turkey, Swiss |
| Smoked Ham | $10.89 | 712 | Ham, Swiss |
| Roast Beef | $10.89 | 614 | Angus roast beef, provolone |
| Tuna Salad | $10.89 | 685 | Albacore tuna salad, Swiss |
| PB&J | $9.99 | 605 | Peanut butter, grape jelly |
| Grilled Cheese | $9.99 | 420 | Cheddar only |
Top 5 Must-Try Potbelly Sandwiches
- A Wreck – A legendary meat combo with turkey, ham, beef, and salami.
- Italian – The spicy, zesty king of toasted subs.
- Farmhouse Chicken – (Tip: Add bacon for $1.50)
- Chicken Salad – Creamier than your local deli’s.
- Avo Turkey – Balanced and satisfying.
Best Budget Pick: PB&J
Most Calories: Mama’s Meatball
Lightest Sandwich: Veggie Melt
Potbelly Secret Menu & Ordering Hacks
Potbelly Sandwich fans know that there are more items than listed on the board. Here’s how to access the secret Potbelly sandwich menu:
Secret Items
- Spicy Wreck: A Wreck + jalapeños + pepper relish
- Pizza Sub: Italian with marinara sauce
Money-Saving Tips
Customization Tips
| Upgrade | Price |
|---|---|
| Extra Meat | $2.50 |
| Double Cheese | $1.00 |
| “Well-Done” Toasting | Free |
Nutrition & Dietary Options
Calorie Ranges
- Lightest Sandwich: Veggie Melt – 430 cal
- Heaviest Sandwich: The Wreck – 720 cal
Dietary Notes
- Gluten-Free: Order any sandwich as a salad
- Vegetarian Options: Veggie Melt, Mediterranean (no chicken), Grilled Cheese
- Vegan Option: Mediterranean (no feta)
Healthier Combos
- Veggie Melt on multigrain
- Turkey Breast, no mayo
- Chicken Salad (half-portion)
Potbelly Ordering Guide: Delivery, Takeout, or Dine-In?
Delivery
- Available via DoorDash and Uber Eats
- Fees range from $2.99 to $4.99 depending on region
Takeout
- Use the Potbelly app for priority orders
- Call ahead for catering or large groups
Dine-In
| Best Time | Why |
|---|---|
| After 2pm | Shorter lines, fresher batches |
| Avoid 12–1:30pm | Peak lunch rush |
Payments Accepted
- Visa, Mastercard, AmEx
- Apple Pay & Google Pay available in-store and on app
Potbelly Locations & Hours
Potbelly operates 500+ stores across the U.S. Here are the key regional insights:
By Region
| Region | Highlights |
|---|---|
| Northeast | NYC stores open till 10pm |
| Midwest | 200+ locations, including original Chicago shop |
| South | Texas stores offer sweet tea |
| West Coast | California allows avocado on any sub |
Potbelly Hours
- Weekdays: 10:30am–9pm
- Weekends: 11am–8pm
FAQs About Potbelly Sandwich Menu
1. What is Potbelly’s most popular sandwich?
A Wreck is the top seller, followed closely by the Italian.
2. Does Potbelly offer gluten-free bread?
No, but you can turn any sandwich into a salad.
3. Does Potbelly serve breakfast?
No. They start lunch service at 10:30am.
4. How much is a full Potbelly meal?
Around $10–$15, including sandwich, chips, and drink.
5. Can I customize my sandwich?
Yes. Add extra meat, swap cheese, or request “well-done” toast.
6. Are there vegetarian options?
Yes. Try the Veggie Melt, Grilled Cheese, or Mediterranean (meat-free).
7. Which sandwich has the lowest calories?
Veggie Melt at 465 cal.
8. Is Potbelly more expensive than Subway?
Generally yes, but the quality and ingredients are better.
9. Can I use digital wallets?
Yes. Apple Pay and Google Pay are accepted.
10. What’s the best deal on the menu?
Family Bundles: $22 feeds 4.
11. Is there a secret menu?
Yes! Spicy Wreck and Pizza Sub are among fan favorites.
12. Are nutrition facts available in-store?
They are posted online and in the app.
13. Can I request sandwiches without toasting?
Yes. Just ask for “untoasted.”
14. Do calories include sauces?
Yes, standard toppings are included in the count.
15. Which Potbelly sandwich is best for protein?
The Wreck or Prime Rib Steak offer the most meat per bite.
Final Thoughts
Potbelly Sandwich isn’t just a toasted sub. It’s an experience—from the smell of baking bread to the crunch of “well-done” toast and the extra hit of flavor from those hot giardiniera peppers.
With customization, regional twists, secret menu hacks, and quality ingredients, Potbelly in 2025 delivers more than just food. It delivers satisfaction.
Whether you’re a first-timer exploring the Italian or a regular returning for your weekly A Wreck, this menu guide ensures you get the most value, taste, and experience every single visit.
Now you know what to order. Time to make it toast