Price: $2.79 | Calories: ~390 Cal (per cookie)
View Full: Potbelly Menu With Prices
Order now: PbDelivery®
Nutritional Information
| Nutrient | Amount |
|---|---|
| Calories | ~390 Cal |
| Total Fat | 16 g |
| Saturated Fat | 8 g |
| Cholesterol | 30 mg |
| Sodium | 210 mg ⚠️ |
| Total Carbohydrates | 56 g |
| Dietary Fiber | 1 g |
| Sugars | 31 g |
| Protein | 4 g |
(Values may vary depending on store baking and portion size.)
What’s Inside the Potbelly Sugar Cookie?
- Flour – classic base
- Butter & eggs – rich bakery flavor
- Sugar – sweet and simple
- Vanilla – warm aroma
- Baking soda + salt – balanced texture
The Potbelly Sugar Cookie is a simple, classic treat baked fresh daily, perfect for those who want a sweet finish without too many extras.
Is It Vegetarian or Vegan?
- ✅ Vegetarian-friendly
- ❌ Not vegan (contains butter and eggs)
Gluten-Free
| Cookie | Gluten-Free? |
|---|---|
| Sugar Cookie | ❌ No |
Allergen Information
| Contains | May Contain |
|---|---|
| Wheat (Gluten), Milk, Eggs, Soy | Tree Nuts (possible cross-contact) |
Why Fans Love the Potbelly Sugar Cookie
- Baked fresh daily – warm, soft texture
- Classic flavor – light vanilla sweetness
- Perfect with milk, coffee, or shakes
- Affordable indulgence – just $2.79
Best Pairings at Potbelly
| Pairing Item | Why It Works |
|---|---|
| Vanilla Shake | Classic combo with sugar cookie sweetness |
| Cold Brew Shake | Coffee + cookie indulgence |
| Oreo Shake | Cookies on cookies |
| Turkey Breast Sandwich | Savory + sweet balance |
| Farmhouse Salad | Light meal with sweet finish |
| Zapp’s Chips + Cookie | Crunch + soft chew in one meal |
| Mac & Cheese | Comfort food heaven |
| Hot Peppers Jar (at home) | Spice + sweet treat contrast |
FAQs about Potbelly Sugar Cookie
1. How much does the Sugar Cookie cost?
It costs $2.79.
2. How many calories are in one cookie?
Around 390 calories per cookie.
3. Is it baked fresh daily?
Yes ✅ – Potbelly bakes all cookies fresh in-store.
4. Is it vegetarian?
Yes ✅ – it does not contain meat.
5. Is it vegan?
No ❌ – contains butter, eggs, and milk.
6. Is it gluten-free?
No ❌ – made with wheat flour.
7. Can I buy it in bulk?
Yes ✅ – available in the 6-Pack Cookie Box.
8. Does it contain nuts?
No direct nuts, but possible cross-contact may occur.
9. Can I order it online?
Yes ✅ – via Potbelly app, website, or delivery platforms.
10. Can I pair it with a shake?
Absolutely ✅ – especially Vanilla or Cold Brew Shake.
11. Is it soft or crunchy?
Mostly soft and chewy with a light crisp edge.
12. Can it be reheated?
Yes ✅ – warm it slightly for bakery-fresh taste.
13. Is it available year-round?
Yes ✅ – it’s a Potbelly staple dessert.
14. Is it kid-friendly?
Yes ✅ – mild sweetness makes it perfect for children.
15. Is it the lightest Potbelly cookie?
Yes ✅ – lower calories than chocolate-based cookies.